Lemon Law for Leased Vehicles

A leased vehicle can be a lemon just like a purchased one, and many state lemon laws protect the person leasing it. The main differences show up at the end. A lease has two parties with money in the car, you and the leasing company, so a buyback refund is split between you. Some states also block early termination charges when a lemon law case ends the lease.

This page explains how that usually works. The details vary by state, so treat the state examples here as examples, not a summary of every state's law.

Does the lemon law cover leased vehicles?

In many states, yes. The lessee is often written right into the definition of who the law protects:

• Florida defines a consumer as "the purchaser, other than for purposes of resale, or the lessee" of a motor vehicle used mainly for personal, family or household purposes (Fla. Stat. §681.102).
• Massachusetts defines a consumer as "a buyer or lessee, other than for purposes of resale" (G.L. c. 90, §7N½).
• New York defines a consumer as "the purchaser, lessee or transferee, other than for purposes of resale" (N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law §198-a(a)).

The rest of the claim usually works the same way as a purchase. The defect has to be covered by the manufacturer's warranty, it has to substantially impair the vehicle, and the manufacturer has to get a fair number of repair attempts. Our pages on repair attempts and deadlines cover those rules.

Who is the consumer in a lease?

You are, as the person driving and paying for the car, but the leasing company owns it. That split shapes the whole case.

You, the lessee, deal with the defect, take the car in for repairs and bring the claim. The lessor holds title. Florida defines the lessor as the person who "holds title to a motor vehicle that is leased" or holds the lessor's rights under the lease (Fla. Stat. §681.102).

Some states add conditions to lessee coverage:

A short-term rental usually won't fit these definitions. Check your state's lemon law page for the exact wording where you live.

How a lease buyback refund works

A lease buyback usually pays two people: you get back what you paid, and the lessor gets back what it's still owed. Florida and New York write this split into the statute.

In Florida, the statute says: "The lessee shall receive the lessee cost and the lessor shall receive the lease price less the lessee cost" (Fla. Stat. §681.104(2)(b)). Lessee cost means "the aggregate deposit and rental payments previously paid to the lessor," not counting debt from any other transaction (§681.102). Lease price is the capitalized cost plus items like the lessor's earned rent charges, collateral charges and some fees and taxes (§681.102).

In New York, the lessee receives the "capitalized cost," which the statute defines as the "aggregate deposit and rental payments previously paid to the lessor for the leased vehicle less service fees." The lessor receives the lease price less those payments (N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law §198-a(a), (c)(2)).

In Massachusetts, for a leased vehicle that is returned, the manufacturer "shall refund all payments made by the consumer to the manufacturer under the terms of the lease agreement," less any accepted cash award and a reasonable allowance for use, or offer a replacement (G.L. c. 90, §7N½).

Once the refund is paid, you give the car back. Florida says that on receipt of the refund or replacement, the consumer, lienholder or lessor must give the manufacturer clear title and possession (Fla. Stat. §681.104(2)(a)).

What happens to your lease payments and use offset

Your past lease payments are usually the core of your refund, though a use offset may come out of it. Many lemon laws let the manufacturer subtract a reasonable amount for your use of the car, and leases are no exception.

Florida shows how a state can adapt that math to a lease. Its "reasonable offset for use" multiplies the miles attributable to the consumer, up to the settlement or arbitration hearing, by the vehicle's price, then divides by 120,000 (60,000 for a recreational vehicle). For a lease, the price used is "the agreed-upon value as reflected in the lease agreement" (Fla. Stat. §681.102).

Other states use different formulas, and some leave the amount to the arbitrator or court. Our buyback and replacement page explains the common patterns.

Early termination and the end of the lease

A lemon law refund ends the lease, and some states forbid charging you a penalty for that. Florida says "a penalty for early lease termination may not be assessed against a lessee who receives a replacement motor vehicle or refund under this chapter" (Fla. Stat. §681.104(2)(b)). New York says the lease ends on the date of the arbitrator's decision and "no penalty for early termination shall be assessed" (N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law §198-a(c)(2)).

Ending a lease on your own is different. If you turn the car in early outside the lemon law process, your lease contract's early termination terms apply. Get advice before you hand back the keys.

Questions about your vehicle's repair history?

Tell us what has happened with your vehicle. A member of our team will look at your dates and repair orders with you. Reaching out does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Check my vehicleCall (888) 884-8551

Replacement vehicles on a lease

The manufacturer may offer a new vehicle instead of a refund. In several states, you get to decide. Florida gives the consumer "an unconditional right to choose a refund rather than a replacement motor vehicle" (Fla. Stat. §681.104(2)(a)). Massachusetts gives an "unqualified right to reject a manufacturer's offer of replacement and demand a refund."

Massachusetts adds a lease-specific protection. When a leased vehicle is replaced, the dealer or manufacturer can't require you to sign a lease that creates financial obligations "beyond those implied by the original lease agreement" (G.L. c. 90, §7N½). Before you agree to a swap, compare the new lease terms line by line with the old ones.

Magnuson-Moss and leased vehicles

The federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act may help a lessee, but its text doesn't mention leases. It defines a consumer as a buyer (not for resale), "any person to whom such product is transferred during the duration of an implied or written warranty," and anyone entitled by the warranty or state law to enforce it (15 U.S.C. §2301(3)).

Whether a lessee fits one of those groups depends on the warranty, the lease and how the court reads the definition. Where it applies, the law's duties under a full warranty "extend from the warrantor to each person who is a consumer" (15 U.S.C. §2304(b)(4)). State lemon laws that name lessees outright are usually the more direct route. Our Magnuson-Moss page covers the federal law.

How state rules differ for leases

States agree on the big idea but differ on the details. The most common differences are:

• Coverage: Some states name lessees outright. Others require a minimum lease term, such as one year.
• Refund split: States define what the lessee gets back (deposits, payments, sometimes less service fees) and what the lessor gets in different ways.
• Early termination: Some states ban penalties when a lemon law refund or replacement ends the lease. Others may not address it.
• Turn-in charges: New York's attorney general runs a separate arbitration program for "excess wear and tear" charges on leased cars.

Your state's page lists the rules where you live.

What to keep if your leased car is a lemon

Keep the paperwork for both the lease and the repairs:

• the lease agreement, including the capitalized cost and any amounts paid at signing
• a payment history from the leasing company
• the manufacturer's warranty booklet
• every repair order, with dates, mileage and your description of the problem
• letters, emails and texts with the dealer, the manufacturer and the leasing company

Our guide on how to document repair visits explains what to ask for each time the car goes in. If you're unsure where you stand, start with does my vehicle qualify.